Response to reviewer
Response to Reviewer Comments
Unrealistic target journals, poor paper construction, poor research design, lack of novelty, irrelevant clinical research, unrealistic timeframes, improper English, plagiarism–these are some of the many aspects of writing you must steer clear of if you want your manuscript to be selected.
At Quillcraft, experienced editors show you the way forward and guide you through this cumbersome process. Experts advise you on everything from conceptualizing novel ideas to responding to your reviewers. We are with you until you successfully publish your journal.
Our Reviewier Comments Process
Carefully gathering thoughts
Review the comments attentively, gathering your thoughts before responding to them. Afterwards, revisit the comments with a fresh perspective to identify the modifications requested by the reviewers and editors for your manuscript.
Track changes
Use track changes or different colour to clarify revised text in the manuscript
You get a detailed report
Please enclose a separate sheet detailing your responses to referee comments. Ensure that referee comments are integrated into your response. Address each comment individually in your response. Begin by stating clearly whether the suggested actions were implemented or not, followed by an explanation for the decision.
Address each reviewer's comments individually but within a single response, distinguishing between Reviewer A and B's feedback for each comment.
What We Provide
It’s rare for articles to be accepted without revisions as peer reviewers assess the suitability of content for publication, often raising crucial questions to enhance its quality. Understanding and accurately interpreting reviewer comments is vital at this stage, followed by revising the manuscript, submitting a cover letter, and providing clear, point-by-point responses to reviewers’ queries. Our experts will:
- Gather the necessary scientific information and your responses to the reviewers’ comments.
- Substantively edit and refine the responses with your input to improve quality.
- Ensure proper English usage and maintain an appropriate tone.
- Prepare a suitable cover letter.
- Assist in uploading the responses to the journal’s webpage.
Frequently Asked Questions
Welcome to our FAQs on publishing. Here, we aim to help you with any questions or worries about how to publish your work. We know that understanding how to publish in academic and professional fields can be tricky, so we made this guide to make things clearer and easier for you.
Delivery depends on the order type. The trained academic experts at Quillcraft will help you to give good and valid responses to reviewer comments.